One of the things I love about our book club is that whoever is hosting chooses the book which just makes so much sense. Most book clubs that I’ve heard of choose the next book by consensus, which I can only imagine leads to lots of procrastination, debating, arguing and general wasting of time. I think our founder members were very wise to go for the ‘host’s choice’ system instead, it makes things a lot simpler and means everyone gets a turn to pick (and inflict their choice on others. Mwah ha ha ha …)
My turn will be coming up soon (we need to wait and see whose name comes out of the hat next time!) so I’ve been contemplating what to choose for my fellow bookworms. So many books, so little time. Here’s my shortlist so far:
1) Room by Emma Donoghue
Pros: I loved this book and think everyone in the entire world should read it. It’s a perfect book club read as there are so many things to discuss. The narrator is a five-year-old boy and most of us have children around that age so it makes it easier to relate to his mindset and all the more poignant to contemplate what his mother is going through. Plus Helen W has already started it, which means her chances of finishing it should be somewhat higher than her previous record suggests …
Cons: I’ve already read it, and it’s a bit too soon to read it again. I like to read the book in the two weeks or so before the meeting so it’s fresh in my mind.
2) Either Northline or The Motel Life by Willy Vlautin (of Richmond Fontaine fame)
Pros: Both are on my ‘must read’ list (good). And already on my bookshelf (even better). I really loved his other book, Lean on Pete – such a moving read.
Cons: If they’re anything like Lean on Pete and just about every Richmond Fontaine song they’re going to be utterly depressing. Not sure I want to be responsible for bringing everyone’s mood down for the next month.
3) The Double Life of Cassiel Roadnight by Jenny Valentine
Pros: I haven’t read this yet and I adore all her previous books, especially Finding Violet Park. The plot sounds intriguing.It might make an interesting change to read a teenage book. Plus it should be short enough for even Helen W to finish.
Cons: She’s one of those authors who makes me feel depressed that I’ll never, ever be able to write as well as her.
4) The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows
Pros: Another book that I think everyone in the world should read. It’s long enough since I read it that I could happily read it again. It’s a heartwarming read with one of the most endearing heroines I’ve ever come across.
Cons: If anyone criticised it even a tiny bit I might stab them with the cheese knife.
5) Welcome to the World Baby Girl by Fannie Flagg
Pros: Another case of ‘I loved her other book’ (Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe)
Cons: Don’t actually know anything about it.
6) One Day by David Nicholls
Pros: I’ve already started reading it (had to abandon it to start the current book club choice, The Slap by Christos Tsiolkas). It’s one of those books which is talked about a lot so would be good to know what all the fuss is about. My sister recommended it.
Cons: From what I’ve read so far I like it but I don’t love it. I certainly didn’t have any trouble tearing myself away to start The Slap, so that’s probably not a good sign.
7) The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry
Pros: I’ve already read it. Another book I’d love to discuss with my book club, there’s so much to it and lots of things which are not definitively tied up and are open to interpretation, which always makes for an interesting discussion. The language in it is just beautiful.
Cons: I’ve already read it.
Those are my thoughts so far … no doubt I’ll consider and discard about a dozen more titles before my turn comes around! Watch this space, book club peeps (and be grateful I wasn’t pulled out of the hat when I picked The Swan Thieves by Elizabeth Kostova. It’s nearly 700 pages long and my husband was unimpressed by it – very disappointing considering how much I loved The Historian).